VARIOUS: ITALIAN FERTILITY SPECIALIST CLAIMS BREAKTHROUGH IN CONTROVERSIAL HUMAN CLONING PROGRAMME

Record ID: 639539

  • Title: VARIOUS: ITALIAN FERTILITY SPECIALIST CLAIMS BREAKTHROUGH IN CONTROVERSIAL HUMAN CLONING PROGRAMME
  • Date: 11th April 2002
  • Summary: (W8) WASHINGTON, D.C., USA (APRIL 9, 2002) (REUTERS) SOUNDBITE (English) SEAN TIPTON, AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR REPRODUCTIVE MEDICINE, SAYING "In the large animal models there have been lots of problems, there have been repeated miscarriages, there have been flawed offspring, and there has even been some danger to the mother."
  • Embargoed: 26th April 2002 13:00
  • Keywords:
  • Location: WASHINGTON, D.C., LEXINGTON, KENTUCKY, COLLEGE STATION, TEXAS, UNIVERSITY OF HAWAII, HAWAII, AND VARIOUS UNIDENTIFIED LOCATIONS, USA, ROME, ITALY AND EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND, UNITED KINGDOM
  • City:
  • Country: USA
  • Topics: General,Health,Politics,Science
  • Reuters ID: LVA2XJQATT3F6E5RX2S1IC6COPIA
  • Story Text: A report this week by an Italian fertility specialist
    that a woman in a controversial cloning programme is pregnant
    has been greeted with widespread scepticism from the
    scientific community, and reportedly has prompted the U.S.

    based ally of the Italian doctor to cut ties with the program.

    Usually a new baby is the result of joining human
    sperm and egg; but now an Italian fertility expert says that's
    no longer the case. Dr. Severino Antinori's claim that he's
    helped impregnate a patient with the first human clone, has
    made him a lighting rod for outrage.

    So much so that his strongest ally, Dr. Panos Zavos of the
    U.S.-based Andrology Institute, is reportedly cutting ties
    with Antinori. Last year, the two pledged to join efforts to
    produce the first human clone.

    The split marks the latest in the controversy surrounding
    Antinori's clone pregnancy claim, one that many fertility
    experts doubt. Sean Tipton of the American Society for
    Reproductive Medicine said of the report, "I don't think
    there's any reason to believe these claims even if they're
    made are true."
    "The team that has been making these claims has made
    similar claims in the past and they haven't borne out and they
    have offered no scientific evidence to back up their claims,"
    Tipton said on Tuesday (April 9, 2002).

    Antinori made the claim in response to a question during a
    lecture at the Zayed Center for Follow-up and Coordination, an
    Abu Dhabi think tank.

    "Our project is at a very advanced stage. One woman among
    the thousands of infertile couples in the programme is eight
    weeks pregnant," Gulf News, an English-language newspaper in
    the United Arab Emirates, reported Antinori as saying last
    week.

    Antinori will not confirm or deny his claims to any other
    media except an Italian newspaper reporter he told that that
    the baby is a clone of a wealthy Arab, who is providing
    unlimited money to develop human cloning in an Islamic
    country.

    Human embryo cloning is not a completely new process,
    however, it is believed none have been implanted and carried
    to term. While many mammals have been cloned and some seem
    normal in appearance, scientists say they have left a host
    malformed creatures in their path, proving dangerous and
    unethical.

    "In the large animal models there have been lots of
    problems, there have been repeated miscarriages, there have
    been flawed offspring, and there has even been some danger to
    the mother," Tipton told Reuters.

    While she appears normal, even the now-famous Dolly the
    cloned sheep, has reportedly developed severe arthritis at a
    relatively young age.

    "It is clear that this is a technology that's not ready to
    be tried in humans," Tipton said.

    The Rome Medical Association is threatening Antinori with
    disciplinary action if he indeed tried to clone a person.

    Most countries, including Saudia Arabia and Italy, ban human
    cloning. The United States Congress is currently debating a
    measure that would ban it in America.
  • Copyright Holder: REUTERS
  • Copyright Notice: (c) Copyright Thomson Reuters 2015. Open For Restrictions - http://about.reuters.com/fulllegal.asp
  • Usage Terms/Restrictions: None
Register